Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky.

🔑 They invented the utility roll-up in the 1850s

In the 1840s, communication changed forever with the invention of a revolutionary new technology:

The telegraph.

Written messages no longer needed to be physically delivered by train or horse.

But while the telegraph made it possible to send a message hundreds of miles instantly, someone still had to build the lines and maintain them.

The need for a national telegraph infrastructure became one of the greatest roll-up opportunities in early business history.

Let's dive into the story of Western Union.

The mid-1800s U.S. telegraph industry was fragmented.

Dozens of small local and regional companies operated under competing patents and systems.

Messages often required retransmission across multiple networks, causing delays, errors, and high costs. Many smaller firms went bankrupt.

Western Union grew through aggressive acquisitions absorbing numerous independent lines in the 1850s.

Other companies did the same and regional monopolies formed.

In 1857 the six largest companies created a pooling agreement (the “Treaty of Six Nations”) to coordinate major routes, forming a cartel. Those six were:

• American Telegraph Company: Atlantic seaboard and some Gulf states
• Western Union Telegraph Company: states north of the Ohio River and parts of Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, and Minnesota
• New York, Albany and Buffalo Electro-Magnetic Telegraph Company: most of New York State
• Atlantic and Ohio Telegraph Company: Pennsylvania and parts of Ohio
• Illinois & Mississippi Telegraph Company: Parts of Illinois, Iowa, and Missouri
• New Orleans & Ohio Telegraph Company: Southern Mississippi Valley and the Southwest

Further consolidation wasn't feasible until 1861.

That's when the first transcontinental telegraph line was completed.

Construction crews linked the East Coast to California by meeting in Salt Lake City. The project took just 112 days (try imagine that happening today).

This made the Pony Express obsolete almost immediately.

By 1866 Western Union absorbed its last major rivals (including the other largest one, American Telegraph Company).

It reached a near-monopoly controlling roughly 90% of U.S. telegraph traffic.

While it's common today, this was one of the earliest examples of a private firm consolidating an entire national industry through serial acquisitions.

The acquisition playbook we've seen other utility companies, like mobile carriers, internet providers, and cable companies, use well into the 21st century started with Western Union over 150 years ago.

Structure of the Deals

Many deals used stock rather than cash, which was unusual for the time (but is now standard).

In 1881, for instance, Western Union issued large blocks of new stock to acquire rivals:

• $15 million for the American Union Telegraph Company
• $8.4 million for Atlantic and Pacific Telegraph interests it did not already own.

Western Union grew from a value of a few hundred thousand dollars in the mid-1850s to $10 million by 1864 (~$212 million in today's dollars).

Scaling Up

Here's the scale at which volume surged but pricing fell for consumers:

• Messages handled each year by WU:
  • 5.8 million in 1867
  • 9.2 million in 1870
  • 29.2 million in 1880
  • 55.9 million in 1890
  • 63.2 million in 1900.
• Average rates fell from $1.09 per message in the late 1860s to 30 cents by 1900 (but profit margin remained high)
  ​
• Peak era: In 1945 the U.S. telegraph industry handled about 236 million messages and generated roughly $182 million in revenues. Western Union was still the dominant force at that time when long-distance telephone calls were prohibitively expensive.

Decline of Western Union and Other Communications Roll-Ups

Western Union’s telegraph dominance peaked in the late 19th and early 20th centuries but eroded with the telephone’s rise.

Alexander Graham Bell’s 1876 invention of the telephone was a warning sign to telegraph operators, even though the technology still wouldn't truly compete in long-distance communications for decades.

Telegram volume held relatively steady for decades (phones were not yet universal, and telegrams provided a permanent written record), with a high point around the 1940s.

After World War II, competition from telephones, airmail, and newer technologies accelerated the drop.

The company raised rates repeatedly, closed many offices, and watched message volume fall sharply.

AT&T, Bell's company, carried out the same playbook Wester Union used decades earlier. They bought up independent regional operators to form a national telephone system that became a monopoly.

Interestingly, AT&T bought a 30% stake of Western Union in 1909, but was forced to sell it just four years later due to anti-trust concerns from the government.

Western Union is still around today as a money transmitting business, with steadily declining revenue ($4 billion annual revenue now vs. $5.4 billion ten years ago).

Sieva

What did you think of today's newsletter? Rate this newsletter using the poll below:

Disclaimer: nothing here is investment advice. Please do your own research. The information above is just for information and learning.

​​