Learn how to buy businesses in 5-minutes or less, once a week. Lessons & specific tactics on how invest your money and generate cash flow for your life.
π They bought 2 businesses. One failed and one didn't.
|
Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. π 2 nearly identical deals: Why one made 5x and the other failed Private equity loves to buy retail businesses. Staples, Macy's, and PetSmart are a few mega PE buyouts you might know about. But today I want to focus in on two fascinating PE deals that closed just before the 2008 recession. One was a disaster. And one wasn't. Deal #1: Toys "R" Us In March 2005, a consortium of KKR, Bain Capital, and others bought out Toys "R" Us. The deal went down in infamy. Here are the details:
The new owners of the business added billions in debt to the balance sheet and eventually drove the company into bankruptcy within a decade. They also drew scrutiny by pocketing about $450 million in interest and $185 million in advisory fees along the way.
The former leader of the toy industry, Toys R Us filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in September 2017 after years of slipping sales and mounting debt. While intense price competition from mass retailers Walmart, Amazon, and Target has contributed to the companyβs woes, experts place the blame squarely on the shoulders of management. They said Toys R Us has failed to innovate its business model, incorporate technology or adapt to changing consumer behavior.
β The day of reckoning may have been delayed through a $7.5 billion leveraged buyout in 2005 by private investors Bain Capital Partners, Kohlberg Kravis Roberts, and Vornado Realty Trust. But the debt payments proved to be too much for the company,
β - Wharton case study, By the mid-2010s the company was generating operating profit ($378 million in 2015), But interest and capex ate it all up (and then some). Interest expense alone was $450 million annually. The business recorded a net loss of $130 million for 2015. Sadly, that was one of the better years of the decade (the loss was $1 billion for 2013). The business couldn't escape this death spiral of interest payments and a struggling business model. It went bankrupt in 2017. Was this a case of blatant greed by PE? Well, not exactly. Yes, there were some misaligned incentives. But Toys "R" Us was fighting a losing battle against Amazon. They needed billions to retrofit the company from the huge big box store model to an e-commerce business. But they didn't have the time or the cash. Ultimately, the company failed and equity went to zero. Let's take a look at a different deal from the same time. Deal #2: Dollar General Nearly two years after the Toys "R" Us deal, KKR agreed to take Dollar General private at $22 a share. The deal valued Dollar General at $7.3 billion including assumed debt. The deal terms:
The plan was to take Dollar General private, fix up the business's glaring weaknesses, and take it public again for a profit. Some of those weaknesses included:
To close the LBO, the group of investors added about $5.4 billion in new debt to Dollar General. To fund the $22-a-share take-private, the company raised a large new stack of loans and bonds. Around close it expected about $5.4 billion of total debt. The new paper included a $2.43 billion term loan B, plus large senior and subordinated notes (the bond package was resized in the market; one early plan was a $1.9 billion high-yield sale on top of the term loan). Equity from KKR and co-investors was about $2.8 billion, so more than 60% of the ~$7.3 billion enterprise value was debt. β - Supermarket News, June 2007 KKR bought the company just at the right time before credit markets dried up- this deal would not have been possible a year later. And ultimately their new plan worked. Just two years later, they re-IPOd Dollar General after fixing up the company. Because there were several investors and they sold off their stakes gradually over several years, there isn't an exact ROI figure. But here are a few pieces of information we have:
Same strategy, two different results The Toys "R" Us and Dollar General deals look similar at first. They happened around the same time, were for similar amounts, used similar structures, and even had the same investors. Both companies were struggling retailers at the time. So what was the difference? It wasn't the structure that caused Toys "R" Us to fail, like many think. At the end of the day, the turnaround was just too difficult to execute and Amazon was too fierce a competitor by the mid-2010s. There were external forces that caused both business to struggle. Sometimes you have the cash and time to pivot (like Dollar General). And other times, interest expense eats up the business before you can execute a turnaround (like in the case of Toys "R" Us). Sieva What did you think of today's newsletter? Rate this newsletter using the poll below: Disclaimer: nothing here is investment advice. Please do your own research. The information above is just for information and learning. |
Sieva Kozinsky
Learn how to buy businesses in 5-minutes or less, once a week. Lessons & specific tactics on how invest your money and generate cash flow for your life.
Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. π Join the CEO Bootcamp Nick Huber is hosting a CEO Bootcamp on Monday, September 21 to break down the four systems he uses to run his portfolio of companies. He'll cover the strategies he uses to delegate and set targets for his 400+ employees. Plus he'll go over his exact compensation structure. As an investor in Nick's company Somewhere, I know firsthand how skilled he is at building teams, managing processes, and scaling. If...
Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. π They bought a $7 billion oil company (at the exact wrong time) In 1802, a French immigrant started a small gunpowder manufacturing business in Delaware. It later became one of the US military's largest suppliers. And two centuries later, it's one of the largest chemical companies in the world. The company: DuPont. A $17 billion company, DuPont manufactures and sells chemicals and materials like sealant, pesticides, nylon,...
Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. π The deal that defined media M&A for years Media M&A is fascinating to me. Nearly every media property we know of today has been bought and sold many times. The industry is constantly being shaken up. Today, I'm going to give you a brief overview of one of the most consequential deals in media history: The Time-Warner merger. But first you need some context. The end of the 1980s was a transition period for M&A. The LBO machine...