Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. Here's what we have in store for you today:

1. They spent $4 billion - and then the industry collapsed
   ​
2. Don't always be an optimist​
   ​
3. My friend bought 100+ auto shops (here's how)
   ​

🔑 They made a huge acquisition - and then the industry collapsed

I love studying old deals.

It helps me understand what makes a business acquisition successful (or a total flop).

In many cases, luck plays a huge role.

This is one of those cases.

In 2006, Vulcan Materials Company (construction materials business) purchased Florida Rock Industries for $4.6 billion.

The deal closed in early 2007, shortly before the entire construction industry would be rocked by the Financial Crisis.

But the deal still worked out in the end.

Let's take a closer look at this deal:

Summary of the deal:

• Acquirer: Vulcan Materials Company
• Target: Florida Rock Industries, Inc.
• Industry: Construction Aggregates (Crushed Stone, Sand, Gravel, and Concrete)
• Deal Value: $4.6 billion
• Announcement Date: September 2006
• Closing Date: February 2007

Background

Vulcan Materials Company, based in Birmingham, Alabama, is the largest U.S. producer of construction aggregates (the stuff they make cement and asphalt out of), including crushed stone, sand, and gravel, and a major supplier of asphalt and ready-mixed concrete.

Florida Rock Industries, headquartered in Jacksonville, Florida, was a leading producer of aggregates and concrete in the Southeastern United States, with a strong presence in high-growth markets like Florida, Georgia, and Virginia.

Both companies operated in the construction materials industry, a capital-intensive, labor-heavy sector.

Vulcan wanted to grow its footprint in the fast-growing Southeastern US, particularly the booming state of Florida.

However, the timing of the deal couldn't have been worse for Vulcan.

Deal Structure

• Valuation: Vulcan agreed to acquire Florida Rock for $4.6 billion, including $1.6 billion in cash and approximately 28.9 million shares of Vulcan common stock, valued at $3 billion based on Vulcan’s stock price at the time.
• Terms: Florida Rock shareholders received $35.20 in cash and 0.63 shares of Vulcan stock for each Florida Rock share, representing a 36% premium over Florida Rock’s stock price before the announcement.
• Financing: Vulcan funded the cash portion through a combination of debt and existing cash reserves, increasing its debt load significantly. The stock issuance diluted Vulcan’s existing shareholders but aligned with its strategy to use equity as currency for growth.

Vulcan had 5 key goals with this deal:

1. Geographic Expansion: Florida Rock’s operations were concentrated in Florida, Georgia, and Virginia, markets Vulcan wanted a stronger presence in. Florida, in particular, was a high-growth market due to its booming real estate and infrastructure sectors.
2. Market Leadership: The deal solidified Vulcan’s position as the dominant U.S. aggregates producer, increasing its production capacity to over 250 million tons annually and expanding its network of quarries and facilities.
3. Economies of Scale: Combining operations allowed Vulcan to achieve cost synergies through shared logistics, reduced transportation costs, and optimized production. Vulcan estimated annual synergies of $50 million by 2009.
4. Diversification: Florida Rock’s strong concrete business (ready-mixed and precast) diversified Vulcan’s portfolio beyond aggregates, providing exposure to downstream markets.
5. Vertical Integration: The acquisition enhanced Vulcan’s control over the supply chain, from raw aggregates to finished concrete products, strengthening its competitive edge.

The 2008 financial crisis decimated the U.S. construction industry.

Housing starts plummeted, reducing demand for aggregates and concrete. Vulcan’s increased debt load from the acquisition strained its balance sheet during the recession.

The Outcome

• Immediate Impact: The acquisition boosted Vulcan’s scale, adding 60 quarries, 18 asphalt plants, and 82 concrete facilities.
• 2008-12 The 2008 recession hit Vulcan hard, with aggregates shipments dropping 30% by 2009. The company’s debt-to-EBITDA ratio spiked, and its stock price fell from $120 in 2007 to below $40 in 2009. The high premium paid for Florida Rock was criticized as overoptimistic given the market collapse.
• Long-Term Recovery: Vulcan weathered the recession by cutting costs, divesting non-core assets, and focusing on operational efficiency. By 2013, the construction market began recovering, and Vulcan’s expanded footprint in Florida proved valuable as the state’s economy rebounded. The synergies from the deal eventually materialized, with Vulcan achieving $60 million in annual cost savings by 2010.
• Market Position: The acquisition cemented Vulcan’s status as the U.S. leader in aggregates, with a market share far ahead of competitors like Martin Marietta Materials. The deal’s long-term success validated Vulcan’s bet on high-growth regions, despite the short-term pain.

In the end, the deal still worked out.

Vulcan was able to decrease costs to weather the storm.

6 years after closing, Vulcan finally started seeing the benefits from the acquisition.

That's much longer than they originally planned, but the important thing is they didn't face a permanent loss of capital.

One of the most important concepts in M&A is margin of safety:

In this case, Vulcan successfully built in a margin of safety and weathered a massive market fluctuation.

The lesson:

I'm not saying you need to predict when the market will crash. But you should make sure every deal can sustain one if it happens the day after closing.

🔑 Business Buying Thought

If you're buying businesses, you can't just be an optimist.

Things will go wrong.

Key employees will quit a week after you buy the business. Growth won't be consistent. You need to plan for the setbacks.

That's why I stress test every deal we do.

If you’re buying a business, ask yourself: “Would the business survive if revenue dropped 20%?”

Too often business buyers assume everything will go right and they’ll double the business right away.

But if the worst case happens, is the business antifragile enough to live another day until you figure out how to turn the ship around?

🔑 He Rolls Up Auto Shops

I chatted with Logan Leslie, one of the most skilled rollup operators I know.

He owns 100+ automotive shops across the Southeast with more than $150 million + in annual revenue.

Logan chatted with me about why he started a holding company, how he did his first deal, and dozens of other lessons from building his empire.

​Watch on YouTube​

​Listen on Spotify​

​Listen on Apple Podcasts​

​

Have a great day,

Sieva

P.S. - Are you hiring? Get started with top global talent from Somewhere (I'm a customer and investor)

What did you think of today's newsletter? Rate this newsletter using the poll below:

​

Disclaimer: nothing here is investment advice. Please do your own research. The information above is just for information and learning.

​

​

​​

​