🔑 He minted collectibles and a $225 million fortune


Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky.
​

🔑 He minted collectibles and a $225 million fortune

Joe stood outside a bank in 1964, watching the line of people stretching around the block.

They weren’t pulling their savings out of the bank.

Instead, they were waiting to get one of the last circulating silver coins before the Mint stopped making them.

At the same time, newspapers were widely reporting the death of national figure General Douglas MacArthur. These two events were coincidence, but they sparked a business idea for the man watching everyone take coins out of the bank.

Joe Segel had a knack for spotting what people wanted before they knew they wanted it.

Nearly two decades later, he'd create the iconic TV shopping network QVC.

But before that, he started a collectibles business.

People loved collecting silver.

They also loved national heroes like MacArthur.

So Joe started the National Commemorative Society and began selling monthly limited-edition silver medals.

The first ones were farmed out to a contractor but looked a bit rough, so Segel did something bold: He poached Gilroy Roberts, the U.S. Mint’s chief engraver who had just finished designing the Kennedy half-dollar, and the two of them set up their own operation.

That business became the Franklin Mint.

Early on, a surprising chunk of the work was actually making gaming tokens for Las Vegas casinos, which kept the presses busy while the commemorative business found its footing.

But once it did, the business model took off.

Customers rushed to secure their spot for each new collectible that the Franklin Mint created.

The company sold limited-edition sterling silver commemorative medals and coins in monthly or series subscriptions that honored historical figures, events, and institutions.

Segel treated the Franklin Mint less like a traditional mint and more like a high-margin subscription business.

He poured the cash into relentless direct-mail and print advertising. Hundreds of thousands of households received catalogs and monthly offers.

By 1970 sales jumped from under $400k in 1965 to $45.8 million.

In 1973, the year Segel stepped down as chairman, the company did roughly $113 million in revenue and more than $9 million in profit

The perceived scarcity of each collection drove demand.

What if I miss out on this collection that will never be made again?

If your check arrived late, it got mailed right back to you with a polite note. People who got burned once made sure they ordered early the next time.

The medals arrived in beautiful display cases with empty spots waiting to be filled, so the urge to complete the set did a lot of the selling for them. Segel always said he wasn’t a coin collector himself; he just understood the psychology.

The Franklin Mint completed its IPO in 1965, raising $4 million.

By the early 1970s the company was striking pieces for foreign governments as well as American subscribers, and the stock had become a market darling.

Segel stepped back in 1973 while the business was still climbing.

Under new management, the business kept expanding: They started selling plates, porcelain dolls, thimbles, die-cast cars, and elaborate chess sets.

Then Warner Communications paid $225 million for the entire business in 1981.

Within about two years, Franklin Mint’s sales had begun to soften as the collectibles market cooled after the 1980 silver-price crash and as buyer skepticism grew about the long-term value of its “limited” editions.

At the same time, Warner itself was in serious trouble: its Atari video-game and home-computer division collapsed, producing hundreds of millions in losses, a plunging stock price, and vulnerability to a hostile takeover.

Warner was forced into restructuring that included dumping Atari in 1984 and putting non-core assets on the block.

Franklin Mint was one of those assets. It had never been a perfect strategic fit for Warner’s entertainment core business, and the combination of slowing sales at the mint plus Warner’s urgent need for cash and focus made a quick exit attractive.

In 1985 Warner sold a majority stake to Stewart and Lynda Resnick’s American Protection Industries for $167.5 million; roughly $60 million less than it had paid four years earlier. Warner kept a minority interest and the real estate, which it leased back.

Analyst reports at the time say that Franklin Mint “failed to prosper” under Warner. But the larger driver of the rapid, discounted sale was Warner’s own Atari-driven crisis rather than any single catastrophic failure inside the mint.

Even with Warner's mistimed purchase, the collectible business as a whole stayed hot.

The industry’s peak hit around the late 1990s with multi-billion-dollar annual sales across plates, dolls, coins, and models. Catalogs and TV ads promised that a limited-edition plate or a model car would be both a beautiful object and a smart little investment. People signed up for series the way others signed up for book clubs.

The trouble was that most of these items were never really scarce.

"The 1990s collectible business declined sharply due to massive overproduction, speculative market mania, and cultural shifts away from mass-manufactured investments."
​
-
The Athletic

Plus, consumers were moving into the digital age. Physical goods didn't fit as neatly into the world of the personal computer.

As for the Franklin Mint, the company pushed it deeper into celebrity dolls, jewelry, die-cast models, and other licensed collectibles in the 90s. Revenue was still in the hundreds of millions, but growth stopped.

A 1998 lawsuit by the Princess Diana Memorial Fund over unauthorized memorabilia turned into a long, public fight.

The original case was dismissed, and the Resnicks later collected roughly $50 million in settlements from the fund and its lawyers.

But the episode damaged sales and reputation at a bad moment. By the early 2000s the rise of eBay, market saturation, and younger buyers’ lack of interest had collapsed demand. The company stopped making new medals and coins around 2003, closed its stores and museum, and cut most of its staff and catalogs.

In 2006 the Resnicks sold the remaining assets to a private group led by executives from the Morgan Mint. The new owners have kept the name alive mainly through licensing but the original direct-response manufacturing and marketing operation is gone.

Sieva


What did you think of today's newsletter? Rate this newsletter using the poll below:

Disclaimer: nothing here is investment advice. Please do your own research. The information above is just for information and learning.

Sieva Kozinsky

Learn how to buy businesses in 5-minutes or less, once a week. Lessons & specific tactics on how invest your money and generate cash flow for your life.

Read more from Sieva Kozinsky

Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. 🔑 If you’re a business owner looking to improve cash flow, take 60 seconds to read this. It’s time to control your insurance costs. That’s why I recommend taking a look at WithCoverage. I know the team and trust their approach. Most business owners engage an insurance broker to get the “best deal”. But in my opinion, that’s a mistake. Traditional insurance brokers are paid on commission. When your premiums go up, so does their...

Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. 🔑 If you’re a business owner looking to improve cash flow, take 60 seconds to read this. It’s time to control your insurance costs. That’s why I recommend taking a look at WithCoverage. I know the team and trust their approach. Most business owners engage an insurance broker to get the “best deal”. But in my opinion, that’s a mistake. Traditional insurance brokers are paid on commission. When your premiums go up, so does their...

Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. 🔑 If you’re planning to buy a business in the next year, take 60 seconds to read this There’s one bill that almost never makes it into the deal model. It’s the workers’ comp audit. A few months after you close, the carrier checks payroll, job roles and subcontractor costs against what the last owner reported. If employees had the wrong class codes, or the payroll numbers were out of date, the carrier sends a bill. Sometimes a big...