|
Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. Here's what we have in store for you today:
π How to Franchise the Right Way If you're reading this newsletter, you either own a business (maybe several), or you want to own one. And you've probably considered franchising at some point. Franchising can be wonderful. It can also be a disaster. Connor Groce has seen both outcomes up close, and lived to tell about it. βJoin us on Tuesday April 21st at 12 ET for a strategic look at the intersection of franchising and acquisition entrepreneurship. In this webinar, we will cover:
Connor has owned and operated franchise units in multiple systems. He has grown his own portfolio through successful acquisitions and is one of the leading voices at the intersection of ETA and Franchising. He also publishes a weekly newsletter called "Franchise Gateway" and serves as the franchising contributor for Acquiring Minds (one of my favorite podcasts) If there's anyone you're going to learn the franchise business from, it needs to be Connor. βRegister for the Webinarβ π How to build a railroad empire with almost no personal capital In the roaring 1920s, two unassuming Cleveland real estate developers quietly assembled one of the largest railroad empires in American history. And they did it with almost no personal investment. Brothers Oris and Mantis Van Sweringen used sophisticated holding company structures to control tens of thousands of miles of railroad track. But the business didn't last long. Because of their highly-leveraged positions and cross-collateralized structure, the 1929 Crash wiped them out. Let's take a look at how they built the business with leverage - and examine why it wasn't built to last. Acquisitions The Van Sweringen brothers began their careers developing the upscale Shaker Heights area, a suburb outside Cleveland, back in 1905. They wanted to connect their new community with downtown. Back then, that meant acquiring rail lines or buying land to build railways on. This launched their railroad adventures. In 1916 they purchased control of the New York, Chicago and St. Louis Railroad, better known as the Nickel Plate Road, from the New York Central. The 523 mile line cost them 8.5 million dollars, but they put down only a fraction in cash and financed the rest through bonds and loans. The acquisition gave them the route they needed for their Shaker Rapid transit line. Over the following decade the brothers expanded rapidly. They acquired the Lake Erie and Western and the Toledo, St. Louis and Western railroads. These lines were later merged into the Nickel Plate system. In 1923 they added the Chesapeake and Ohio and gained control of the Pere Marquette. By 1924 they had also taken the Erie Railroad. Later they bought a major stake in the Missouri Pacific system. By the peak in 1929 the Van Sweringens controlled approximately 30,000 miles of railroad - that's enough to cover the distance from New York City to Los Angeles over ten times. Their rail lines were worth about $3 billion.
The brothers controlled roughly 30,000 miles of railroad, along with significant real estate developments (including Shaker Heights and the Terminal Tower in Cleveland), with an estimated worth of $3 billion. In todayβs currency, this empire was valued at over $45 billion.
Corporate Structure The true genius, or perhaps the fatal flaw, of the Van Sweringen system lay in its corporate structure. The brothers created a multi layered pyramid of holding companies that allowed them to maintain control while investing very little personal capital. At the top sat the Vaness Company, their personal holding entity in which they held the vast majority of shares. Below that came the General Securities Corporation. The critical vehicle was the Alleghany Corporation, formed in 1929, which held controlling interests in the major operating railroads and intermediate companies such as the Chesapeake Corporation. Each layer typically held just over 50 percent of the company below it. This pyramiding effect meant that a relatively small investment at the top could command enormous assets further down the chain. Outside investors provided most of the capital through stock and bond issuances, yet the Van Sweringens retained voting control at every level through carefully structured ownership and interlocking directorates. The result was remote control of a vast network with minimal equity commitment from the brothers themselves. 1929 Crash The stock market crash of October 1929 and the ensuing Great Depression exposed the vulnerabilities of this highly leveraged model. Railroad revenues collapsed as industrial activity slowed dramatically. At the same time, the market value of the assets plunged. Lenders got nervous. The Van Sweringens found themselves unable to meet interest payments and margin calls on their heavily financed positions. And because of their tangled structure, all of the assets were cross-collateralized with each other. By the mid 1930s the empire was in serious distress. In May 1935 they defaulted on a $48 million loan from J.P. Morgan and Company. Creditors forced the sale of collateral at auction. Although the brothers managed to repurchase some of their core properties for just over three million dollars with new backing, the original structure was shattered. Mantis Van Sweringen died in December 1935, followed by Oris in November 1936. Their once mighty railroad holdings were largely dispersed. Lessons for Business Buyers As we've seen many times in this newsletter, leverage can help you build an empire fast- but it can also destroy everything quickly. The brothers purchased valuable assets by borrowing money. But high leverage can create a death spiral - when your cash flow decreases, your debt-servicing costs can often go up because of the decline in the underlying assets' value. Sieva P.S. - Are you hiring? Get started with top global talent from Somewhere (I'm a customer and investor) What did you think of today's newsletter? Rate this newsletter using the poll below: Disclaimer: nothing here is investment advice. Please do your own research. The information above is just for information and learning. |
Learn how to buy businesses in 5-minutes or less, once a week. Lessons & specific tactics on how invest your money and generate cash flow for your life.
Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. Here's what we have in store for you today: Want to get your business in front of my audience? 90 years to build an empire; but it was taken apart in 2 πMarket your business to Sieva's Business Business Academy audience We began testing with our first advertisers last year, and it turns out this community is incredibly engaged. With 70,000 operators, investors, and "acquisition curious" reading this letter each week, we drove...
Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. Here's what we have in store for you today: Want to get your business in front of my audience? Growing from $800 million to $22 billion πMarket your business to Sieva's Business Business Academy audience We began testing with our first advertisers last year, and it turns out this community is incredibly engaged. With 70,000 operators, investors, and "acquisition curious" reading this letter each week, we drove customers for...
Welcome to The Business Buying Academy with Sieva Kozinsky. Here's what we have in store for you today: Want to get your business in front of my audience? Ted Turner's $1.5 billion bet on old movies πMarket your business to Sieva's Business Business Academy audience We began testing with our first advertisers last year, and it turns out this community is incredibly engaged. With 70,000 operators, investors, and "acquisition curious" reading this letter each week, we drove customers for...